Home » On Screen » Movie Reviews & Features
RSS XML


Moon

Space is not the place, in this drama set on the moon


BY HARRY KLOMAN

It's lonely out in space: Sam Rockwell

It's lonely out in space: Sam Rockwell
Duncan Jones is no pup: He's 38 years old, so he's had time to get all of those inchoate ideas out of his eager young head and come up with something at least a little more complex and mature. And yet, in his debut feature film, all he can muster is a dreary tale about a corrupt energy company set in the year 2026, not quite far enough in the future for it to seem futuristic.

Moon opens with a nice sequence that plays like one of those corporate commercials they air on the Sunday-morning political talk shows. But it's part of the movie, an ad for Lunar Industries Ltd., which mines clean and abundant Helium 3 from the moon and brings it back to Earth.

The company's lunar station has one employee, Sam Bell (Sam Rockwell), who's about to fulfill his three-year contract. He's eager to get home to his wife and daughter, who was born just before he left. But then something happens: He's in an accident while out driving the rover, and when he awakens in sick bay, he's being cared for by -- Sam Bell.

Turns out he's a clone, one of a series of Sam Bells who have worked on the station over the years. The two Sams don't get along well at first, but when they realize they're in this together, they begin to conspire to save their life. They have a bit of an ally in Gerty 3000 (Kevin Spacey), their computer-cum-robot, who talks with them just as HAL 9000 did in 2001, but who's more on their side than on the company's.

Jones' movie is a catalogue of unanswered questions and missed opportunities, a novel in short-story form, like something done by a student in his first fiction-writing class who's read too much (or not enough?) science fiction. Its themes are as banal as its story is dull. Is memory real? Is identity? Like, who are we, man? Who am I? I'm talking 'bout the man in the mirror.

Rockwell gives two very strong performances in Moon, playing his character at two different levels of awareness in their lives. But because it is the same actor, Jones can only do so much with them visually, and after a while, his need to keep them apart, or to use the back of a body double for scenes where they come together, feels more self-conscious than watching Godzilla eat Tokyo.

Once you realize how little else is going on in Moon, its center becomes the relationship that develops between the two Sam clones, who evolve into each other's caretaker. So I think Jones should have cast twins in the role, allowing himself more flexibility in working with his actors and his camera. Twins are, after all, the closest thing to clones that we have. I don't see that changing too much between now and 2026.

 

Starts Fri., July 10.


-- E-mail us about this story



Advertisement



Share this article:
Del.icio.us  digg  facebook  Google Bookmarks  Technorati 

COMMENTS
There are no comments yet for this story. You can be the first.

Post a comment




MORE BY HARRY KLOMAN
Life During Wartime
Solondz's companion film to his masterpiece, Happiness, revolves around three Jewish sisters living in contemporary Florida, but the war of his title is the war at home and within. One (Allison Janney) has met a man, but her ex – jailed for child molestation – is now free. Another sister's (Shirley Henderson) husband makes obscene phone calls. As the stories of Life During Wartime unfold, the drama grows bleaker and the comedy grows blacker. There is a central question: How do we forgive and forget, and can we even do one or the other? Solondz's characters are joyless, or they think they're happy when we know they're not. Solondz seems to have no hope for us, and I'm fine with that point of view: His films are funny, original and absorbing to watch, and filled with countless little observations about everyday selfishness, compliance and dysfunction. He's an unsettling filmmaker in a culture that craves disingenuous happy endings. Starts Fri., Aug. 27. Regent Square (Harry Kloman) [3 out of 4 stars] [August 26, 2010]
Get Low
A hermit named Felix (RoBert Duvall) living outside a small town in Tennessee, circa, 1930, comes down from the hills for his own funeral. He hires an undertaker (Bill Murray), who agrees to honor Felix's request: He wants a funeral party, while he's still alive, and he wants everyone who knows a story about him to come and tell it. This is more than enough to suffice a cagey fable filled with characters who are real characters. But Felix has a secret that made him withdraw from the world -- it involves a woman (Sissy Spacek) who remembers him fondly, but who may not when she learns the truth. Get Low is the best 100 minutes I've spent at the movies in a long time. The acting alone is thrilling, with Duvall the centerpiece: alert, serene and deliberate in a way that calls up everything he's learned as an artist. Despite its persistent sadness, Get Low is also a black comedy, and Murray's character especially displays a benevolent whimsy that gets him through the exigencies. Director/editor Aaron Schneider, in his feature-film debut, handles the delicately written screenplay with the dexterity of an experienced filmmaker. When Felix finally tells his tale, it's one we've heard before, but it's so well told that it's moving once again. In the end, Get Low proves that while there are no new stories left to tell, there are still good movies left to make. Starts Fri., Aug. 27. (Harry Kloman) [3.5 out of 4 stars] [August 26, 2010]
Eat Pray Love
Based on the best-selling memoir, and directed by Ryan Murphy, this is a movie about living a better life -- and it cost me two hours and 10 minutes of my life that I'll never get back. When the story of Eat Pray Love begins, Liz Gilbert (Julia Roberts) is a successful New York writer who leaves her husband. Thus begins a new and uncertain phase in her life, and a journey of self-discovery. "Eat" takes place in Italy, where she decides not to feel guilty about gaining a few pounds. "Pray" takes her to India, where she lives at an ashram and meets an American (Richard Jenkins). Finally, she finds "Love" in Bali with a Brazilian businessman (Javier Bardem), and she helps a single mother, divorced from her abusive husband, buy a dream home. This all supposedly happened to Gilbert, but it feels more like Murphy, who co-wrote the screenplay, simply made it up. Everything about Eat Pray Love is aggressively inauthentic: Liz narrates her odyssey, so we're told everything we need to experience, and time after time, she explains the lessons that we never see dramatized. What we get instead is a series of stock encounters, banal insights and bland sit-com humor. (Harry Kloman) [1 out of 4 stars] [August 19, 2010]

My Profile | My Settings
Promo E-mail Sign up  |  Win Free Stuff  |  Advertising Info  |  Contact Us  |  Freelance/Intern Guide  |  Comments/Privacy Policy
Powered by Gyrosite © Copyright 2010, Pittsburgh City Paper   RSS
Real Time Web Analytics